Cats seized from Voice of the Animals sanctuary Posted: Thursday, Sep 07, 2006 - 09:21:33 am PDT By KEITH KINNAIRD News editor
--Photo by KEITH KINNAIRD A Humane Society worker catalogs cats during a search of Voice of the Animals' Camelot sanctuary in Blanchard.
BLANCHARD -- More than 300 cats, many of them sick and dying, were seized Wednesday from a controversial cat sanctuary as part of an animal cruelty investigation.
Bonner County Sheriff's deputies served a search warrant at Voice of the Animals' Camelot sanctuary at 1031 Stone Rd. with the help of officials from the Humane Society of the United States.
"Right now we're just trying to grasp the magnitude of the situation," Sheriff Elaine Savage said.
The Humane Society inspected the property a year ago and found hundreds of cats living in as many as nine trailer homes. Nearly all of the trailers were in severe disrepair and only one of them had running water, according to the October 2005 inspection report.
Excrement was accumulating on floors and smeared on walls in some of the units. Inhabiting the trailers were scores of cats stricken with fleas, ringworm lesions and upper respiratory ailments, the report said.
Deputy Prosecutor Louis Marshall said the county and Humane Society had no reason to believe conditions had improved during the 11 months since the Humane Society inspection.
Misdemeanor animal cruelty charges are pending against Camelot's operators, Edwin J. Criswell, 43, and Cheryl L. Perkins, 58.
"They were cooperative," Marshall said of Criswell and Perkins, neither of whom were placed under arrest.
Marshall declined to say exactly where the animals are being held while the investigation is being conducted.
"They are going to be kept at a secured facility in Bonner County," he said, declining to elaborate.
Humane Society officials wore respirator masks and impermeable Tyvek suits as they took an inventory of all the cats in the mobile homes and fetched carriers for the animals to be transported in.
The stench of feces and decomposition was prevalent.
Veterinarians on the scene were deciding which cats could be saved and which ones should be euthanized, said sheriff's Lt. Jim Drake.
One county official working the scene said the sanctuary's conditions were unlike anything he had witnessed before.
Voice of the Animals is a non-profit group which operates Camelot, a no-kill facility which specializes in taking in sick and terminally ill cats.
The group has fallen on hard times during the last year, said Criswell. Its board acrimoniously parted ways with its principal financier and the Stone Road property is in foreclosure. The well on the property was also found to be tainted by a naturally occurring lead deposit.
Criswell disputes the animal cruelty allegations, but admits conditions at the sanctuary are unsanitary.
"Our main consideration is their health. We spend 20 hours a day with each animal making sure they are healthy," he said.
Excluding kittens, Criswell said there were 344 cats at Camelot at last count. Criswell estimated 20 percent of the cats are so sick they could not be reasonably adopted.
Voice of the Animals was given the choice of giving up the cats voluntarily or having them taken from them through court proceedings.
Criswell said he voluntarily gave up the animals, but made the decision under duress.
ade ellersick wrote on Sep 17, 2006 2:03 PM:
" i am a neighbor and many times traveling down stone rd going by the pet sancturay people in cars would stop to ask me where the place was. the shelters in Sandpoint and kootenai county sending people with animals. they knew the conditions there. its been in the news before. it was probably very difficult to turn the animals away. maybe the shelters should go to court and be held accountable also. they helped compound the problem. come on shelters, step up to the plate..... "
Overwhelmed wrote on Sep 8, 2006 9:48 AM:
" Consider that these people did not ignore the stray cat problem as so many do, and although they were not successful in doing something about it that is a lot more than so many others. I try to spay or neuter any stray feline that comes around & get it some vaccinations but I have yet to be able to find a home for any of those strays. What is a person supposed to do if they can't just take a gun out and shoot someone else's thoughtless behavior, even if that was a moral option. "
Karyn Vanderburg wrote on Sep 8, 2006 9:31 AM:
" I feel sorry for the kitties - but I also feel sorry for the operators. I volunteered at a no kill animal shelter, and it is so difficult to get funding and also to get legitimate adoptors. People want cute, little kittens and when they grow up to be big, beautiful cats they are tossed aside like garbage. The shelter that I volunteered at could have adopted kittens 24/7 but it seems few people want to adopt a full-grown cat. "
Shelley Kaufman-Young wrote on Sep 8, 2006 8:06 AM:
" This is exactly why we need a responsible spay/neuter program as well as a network of fosters to be a backup for sanctuaries such as Camelot that financially cannot continue to be a place of last resort for the animals who are too ill to be adoptable. How could the Humane Society (was it local or the National Humane Society) able to pass the sanctuary last year and then discover it was not healthy this year. How on earth could this be allowed to occur.
just my 2 cents. "
enlightened wrote on Sep 8, 2006 7:24 AM:
" These people are mentally ill. They hoard animals like some people hoard stuff. The laws in Idaho and Bonner County concerning animal control and the ability are what need to be changed. Also, there's that big problem of WHO pays for this operation. While people scream about paying taxes, where do you think the money comes from to pay for any government agency to fix a problem that many folks say is their personal constitutional right? So, maybe it is time for everyone to understand the reality of these problems and understand that it costs money to fix....your money! "
NC Smith wrote on Sep 7, 2006 8:38 PM:
" Let us not forget the grand principle of Don Quixote in regards the cat sanctuary issue. Regardless of these final results, the folks did start out with a "noble" enterprise: the saving of lost little kittie lives. (I'm a dog person) But, like so many do-good sceames, exhaustion and endless expense, and the battleing of bureauocracy has taken it's final toll on the endeavor. With the foreclosure of the property, how much more sad could it get for these cat saviors who failed in the end, anyway.
At least follow the trail of tears back to its beginning, and give the cat sanctuary folks at least a nod for their futile efforts for all of these years. There's plenty of kitties in the past that DID benefit from the sanctuary's efforts. Better than a skeleton in the drainage ditch, isn't it? "
Arayna Kessler wrote on Sep 7, 2006 7:38 PM:
" There is much more to this story than y'all know, heard and saw...the amount of time, energy, love, devotions, tears and money involved is tremendous...calls came in from all over the county from folks for help to rescue stray, abandoned, sick animals, yet so little help and funding to help care for them...what has been broadcasted on the news/internet is not the full story at all. the conditions were not optimal or sanitary for many reasons...lack of funding, lack of honest and dependable help and water problems stemming from a well not put in correctly to prevent leaching of harmful lead and nitrates...non of which is the owners fault. It is very difficult to keep up with medical needs of these rescued animals that, by the way, came from much worse conditions and would have suffered and died nasty deaths if not for voa, with limited funds and help. While what y'all have seen and heard appears horrific, there is another side to this. Please do not judge what you do not know fully. "
Evelyn Farmer wrote on Sep 7, 2006 5:59 PM:
" If these were conditions had a start towards thissituatuon, why wasn't something done about it last year before so many cats were affected? This is not only the faulot of the owners, it is also the responsiblity of anyone that was aware of the situation last year. The only thing is that you could go home at night and not think about while the owners had to stay and try and take care of the mess. Shame on all of you for abusing these cats in this manner. Also the owners should have asked for comunity help if they couldn't afford to take care of all these beautiful little babies that had no one to talk for them. These cats must have come from the community so chip in and do your part, not stand by and say how bad the people who tried were. "
Sammie Lewis wrote on Sep 7, 2006 1:58 PM:
" What I’d like to know is why in heaven’s name the Humane Society of the United States left these poor animals to suffer and die in these conditions since October 2005? That’s the last donation I make to them!!
Sammie Lewis
"
Dave Elmore wrote on Sep 7, 2006 11:55 AM:
" I am surprised the county took so long with their investigation..How many died while the county drug their feet "
POST YOUR OPINION
* All comment posts will encounter a possible delay of up to 24 hours.
ade ellersick wrote on Sep 17, 2006 2:03 PM: